Home » Dessert » Classic Rice Pudding Recipe

Classic Rice Pudding Recipe

This is my go to rice pudding recipe. Maybe it is a dish that you have no choice but to love that’s why I liked every version I’ve tried! Today I give you a classic, an old fashioned creamy version.

A close shot of rice pudding image taken from the side.

If you like your rice pudding without eggs then I have shared a recipe for Rice pudding with caramelized bananas which I think you will love, but for now, let me tell you a little more about this classic delight.

Usually, short grain rice is used to make rice pudding since it has more starch and gives a thicker and creamier texture.

How to Make Classic Rice Pudding Recipe

creamy rice pudding served in a bowl with spoons on the side.

I, however, used long grain rice because it is what I had at home and personally I don’t think it makes much difference since you’ll have a creamy rice pudding even when using long grain rice. The best part is, everything is done in one pot.

A scooping out creamy rice pudding with a spoon.

 

Close up shot of rice pudding in a spoon showing the creamy texture.

There are few things that you should keep in mind while making this rice pudding recipe to achieve great results:

  • Soak the rice at least 20 minutes before cooking.
  • Use full fat milk.
  • Tampering the egg is essential and I’ll show you how.
  • Do not overcook it, you will kill the flavor.
  • Make sure it comes to room temperature before placing it in the fridge.
  • Make sure to cover the rice pudding while in the fridge, the milk absorbs any smell in the fridge.

If you want to use cream and milk, then use 1 ¼ cup milk and ¾ cup cream. Add the cream in the last 2 minutes of cooking time.

These are simple tips to follow but it will make a great difference in flavor and will cut short the cooking time. I have used cinnamon in this recipe, but you can add nutmeg or cloves too.

I’m a person who enjoys the flavor of milk and rice with a hint of spice.

Side shot of homemade rice pudding served in a bowl.

Now let’s make you something sweet?

This page may contain affiliate links, which pay me a small commission
For my referral at no extra cost to you.
Thanks for supporting Arinacooking.com

| |

Classic Rice Pudding. Creamy and delicious, perfect for breakfast, snack, or even dessert. Make it using leftover rice. Have it warm or chilled! letscookingmam.com | @Arinacooking.

2 Comments

  1. Carolyn Daugherty

    Not sure what happened. I followed directions exactly, but this is basically just cooked rice floating around in sweetened flavored milk. It never thickened to the consistency of pudding. Very disappointed!

    • Arinacooking

      Hi Carolyn, I’m sorry this recipe didn’t turn out right for you. My guess, it could be the size of the egg you used since it is what makes the pudding creamy and gives it thickness. If the egg is medium size the pudding will not thicken. If you wish to give this recipe a second try use two medium size eggs instead of one. Also if the rice was not cooked properly (almost soft) it won’t release the starch that will help in thickening the pudding. Hope this helped.